The Fourth River

A journal of nature and place-based writing, published by Chatham University's MFA in Creative Writing Programs

A Second Look: “Creatures That Don’t Exist,” by Chad Hanson

By on October 22, 2014

In this new series, the staff of The Fourth River comb back through our archives to find and share with you the pieces they believe deserve a second look.


Of Mudpuppies & Ear Worms

–by Alex Friedman, The Fourth River Staff


It happens every so often that a bit of language, maybe a sentence or an anecdote or a lyrical turn, sticks in the teeth of the mind. The mind continues to prod at it. Maybe pieces of it click together, and layers of meaning become exposed, and it reveals something profound. This experience is why I chose to take a second look at Chad Hanson’s flash fiction story from issue 10, “Creatures That Don’t Exist.”

The story, weighing in at barely a quarter page, is an ear worm. It initially seems to be two or three lines of thought, barely connected for the reader. But as the story is only seven and a half lines of prose as printed in issue 10, the reader finds themselves rereading it, and then attempting to digest its logic.

In the story, a ‘he’ is portrayed in close third person recounting a scolding received from a third grade teacher when he can’t remember whether a mudpuppy is a real creature or not. His teacher rebukes him for mentioning impossible things, and despite the discomfort of this memory, he tells a folk tale about souls of dead children visiting their parents as nuthatches to his sister, who had just lost a baby in childbirth.

This story at first seems disjointed. But the invested reader might read it again. Perhaps they recount the story to a friend, or think it over in bed or in the shower. However it is reconsidered, enough ‘second looks’ eventually yield that the “him” of this story began to think about mud puppies because of their physical similarities to the unborn human fetus. The story models the internal monologue of a mind trying to cope with the loss of a sibling’s child. The awkwardness of trying to comfort a loved one in the extraordinary pain of losing a child they will never know, the way the mind twists around and looks for connections, all of that is present in this tiny story.

“Creatures That Don’t Exist” rewards multiple readings and the meditation that literary fiction is supposed to inspire. It deserves a second look for its brilliance in construction and for what it leaves unwritten. Stories like Chad Hanson’s are not only a model for excellent storytelling in flash, they also show us the willingness of the mind to analyze art, and what it looks like when a piece seizes the imagination and won’t let go.


Alex Friedman is an assistant fiction editor for the Fourth River. He spends his time reading and writing satire and weird fiction. His fiction recently appeared in Cleveland’s Miser Magazine.

photo 2

Letters from Lindsay House

By on October 6, 2014

I am a person who believes in celebrating one’s own birthday lavishly and extensively. This weekend I did just that with friends and family at my home on Friday night, with my kids at the city’s terrific Children’s Museum on

Wiley Cash

Carolina Minded: An Interview with Wiley Cash

By on June 24, 2014

Interview by Rachael Levitt When bestselling author Wiley Cash passed through Pittsburgh on the promotional tour for his award-winning novel A LAND MORE KIND THAN HOME, he sat down with THE FOURTH RIVER to talk plot tricks and book deals.

Essay: “The Seedbank of Mount Sutro,” by Elizabeth C. Creely

By on May 26, 2014

  Mount Sutro, a hill in San Francisco, is difficult to characterize. At 908 feet, it’s a very tall hill that comes close to being a small mountain. (Another 92 feet, and it would have that distinction.) Many hundreds of

Essay: “Adhering,” by Nicole Parizeau

By on May 15, 2014

Slime (vb.) In part, from the Greek linere: to daub, besmear, rub out. Erase. A fresh and robust slime trail can trap a rolling dime. On a crepuscular sidewalk, from a certain angle (you’ve seen this), a snail trail glows


Interview: Marjorie Agosín

By on April 28, 2014

Interview by Kinsley Stocum   It was an unseasonably warm fall day in Pittsburgh when I talked with Chilean writer and activist, Marjorie Agosín, Chatham University’s All-Campus Author and the woman behind nearly forty books, including anthologies, poetry, memoir and

issue 11 release flyer

What’s New at The Fourth River?

By on April 8, 2014

  Quite a lot, actually, so thanks for asking!   1.       The Fourth River, Issue 11 Release! On Tuesday, April 15th, we will launch issue 11, which features poetry, fiction and creative nonfiction from some terrific writers, including Barbara Hurd,


Book Review: One Summer: America, 1927, by Bill Bryson

By on March 31, 2014

Doubleday 528 pgs/ $16.86 hardcover Review by Ryan Rydzewski “A most extraordinary summer was about to begin.” -Bill Bryson Hundreds of thousands of people gather to watch a New York skyscraper burn. Thousands more crowd Charles Ponzi’s Boston office, desperate


Book Review: Before and Afterlives, by Christopher Barzak

By on March 19, 2014

Lethe Press, March 2013, 225 pages, $15 Review by Kelly Lynn Thomas After reading Christopher Barzak’s short story collection, Before and Afterlives, you might find yourself looking for mermaids among the bikini-clad women swimming at the beach, or for a


Interview: Adam Tavel

By on March 3, 2014

Adam Tavel received the 2010 Robert Frost Award, and his forthcoming collections are The Fawn Abyss (Salmon, 2014) and Red Flag Up (Kattywompus, 2013), a chapbook. His recent poems appear or will soon appear in West Branch, Indiana Review, Zone