By: Mike Bates
They were Sitka spruce, six of them, three mature and three juvenile, surrounding our home on the Cascadia coast, proud members of a subspecies of spruce that grows nowhere else in the world. And they were dying, early casualties of global climate change.
When the arborist told me they needed water, I deflected. Nobody ever told me I’d have to care for established trees when my wife and I retired to the forest ten years ago. If the arborist was suggesting I was guilty of neglect, I wasn’t thrilled with the prospect of undertaking that responsibility, not yet.
They weren’t large, the trees, not by standards of a species that can live upwards of a thousand years and reach three hundred feet in height and nineteen feet in girth. At just sixty feet tall and four and a half feet in diameter, they weren’t any bigger than other trees in the vicinity that had taken root since the lone logging operation during the first decades of the last century.
But they occupied an exposed position on the western flank of the forest, at the event horizon of land and sea, where they’d moderated their growth under the assault of wind, rain, and salt spray. They had a story to tell, and as far as I was concerned, it was different from other Sitka spruce in the vicinity. The three mature trees had long ago shed the cheerful symmetry of youth to take their place, as Scottish botanist David Douglas described their kind more than two hundred years ago, among “the most striking and truly graceful objects in Nature.”
Their trunks were long and straight, bereft of growth from the characteristic flair at their base to a height of forty feet. Proud limbs grew in irregular patterns around their trunks to a length of thirty feet or more, most of them bare from the trunk to a thicket of secondary and tertiary branches at their tips that looked, when covered in short, stiff needles, like enormous hands held upward in supplication.
Their canopies had been shaped by the elements into whimsical figures: one, its trunk split, the Three Graces embraced in dance, chitons billowing in the wind; another, the Winged Nike, wings extended behind her as she set down from flight on one leg; and a third, the largest of them all, a grand old dame I called the Governess for her smart crown, compact and flat in the shape of a boater’s hat, with one limb growing straight up past the crown to explode in a starburst of needles at its tip resembling a parasol.
I wouldn’t know for certain, not unless I’d had them cored, but I had every reason to believe they were between 120 and 140 years of age, not yet old growth, but old enough to be relics of a time when the human inhabitants of the region revered the species more for its resilience and wisdom than its timber. Thick mats of moss climbing their trunks, clumps of lichen called “old man’s beard” growing from their limbs, and wisps of Spanish moss hanging from their needles reinforced the impression of antiquity.
My problem wasn’t from lack of interest, but despair. Periodic drought had weakened the trees against disease and infestation, and warmer temperatures had given a virulent pest, the green spruce aphid, a reprieve from killer frosts. The water table was already low when an extreme heat event hit the region over the summer solstice. The combination of drought, infestation, and searing temperatures had taken most of the needles, and those that remained had started to turn a distressing shade of burnt orange.
I didn’t relish the idea of opening up the spigot for them, “thirty minutes every third day if it doesn’t rain,” as the arborist had prescribed, not when they might be gone no matter what I chose to do. As I continued to vacillate, the oath I felt compelled to offer under her stern gaze, “I’ll be there to the bitter end,” was as much for my benefit as theirs.
The rest of that summer, I went through the motions of watering every third day, without exception. I didn’t have a clue what I was doing, but the promise I’d made kept me going. I’d recite the words every time I set the hose down next to one of them, and I meant it in the most perverse way. As far as I was concerned, “the bitter end” couldn’t come soon enough. What would the neighbors think, many of them long-term residents who would scoff at my credulity if they saw me watering trees in a temperate rain forest?
But after sixty inches of precipitation the ensuing fall, winter, and into spring, something miraculous happened. I found myself near tears one dreary morning in April when I looked out the window above our kitchen sink to see a veneer of new growth covering the lower branches of one of the juvenile spruce. The mature trees would take a little longer, but over the next several weeks, all of them would share that same nascent shade of neon green.
I didn’t know whether their improvement was due to my efforts or the rain, and I didn’t care. I was invested in their condition. The trees had a super-power, the ability to pull themselves back from the dead. Two-hundred and fifty million years of evolution, the last one-hundred and fifty million years as an extant species, the type we know today as spruce, had to count for something. I wasn’t about to let them die, not without a fight.
The following summer, I was able to introduce the water early, as soon as the spring rains subsided. All I had to do was keep the ground moist, not recharge the water table. The location of the hose proved critical, as close to the trunk as possible. Morning water was better than mid-day, and evening water best of all. The ground cover I used to agonize over whenever it spilled over into my garden, that rich undergrowth of vines, fern, and wild grasses, kept the ground shaded and cool. With the correct sprinkler, I could double up my efforts, directing a discrete stream of water against the trunks of two trees at one time with minimum evaporation.
As the summer progressed, I learned the species is capable of absorbing fifty percent of its hydration needs from the air through stomata, microscopic holes at the base of each needle. The cloud of mist atomized on the surf and the pockets of cool, moisture laden air carried inland on the onshore flow proved almost as beneficial as precipitation. Whatever wasn’t absorbed through stomata dropped to the ground like rain to moisten the soil.
By the third summer, I was watering less and with greater effect. And all the while, that practice of reciting my oath every time I dropped the hose next to one of them kept me engaged, though not in the way I’d anticipated.
The routine seemed to ease any inhibitions I might have had from the fact that, by all appearances, I might as well have been talking to myself. With repetition, the meaning of the oath shifted, from something like “dead man walking” to a statement of solidarity. I started to offer the words whenever I happened to look at one of them, not just when I was laying the hose at their feet. Our dialogue would expand from an earnest affirmation of commitment to an ever-expanding commentary on the weather, the forecast, and my schedule for watering, all the way to my appreciation for the meaning they were starting to bring into my life.
At some point, I realized it was my intention that mattered and the emotion with which I acted, not the words I used. Something told me the trees were capable of figuring it out without them. Once I invited them into my thoughts, no topic was too arcane, no emotion too personal. All I had to do was think about one of them, and those trees were privy to the ruminations of an individual who was beginning to think there might be more to the species than meets the eye.
Aristotle postulated that all organisms have a purpose independent of human experience. Neo-Platonists postulated that every organism on the planet might be connected with something akin to universal consciousness. Even the great Augustine, architect of Christian theology, acknowledged that the planet we call Earth might be alive.
Descartes may have put a pin in the neo-Platonic order with his theory of dualism, but since his time, science has eroded the artificial separation of mind and nature. As early as the 1970s, researchers at NASA described the Earth as a cybernetic system that interacts with organisms on her surface to achieve homeostasis.
Over the last several years, neuroscience has expanded the envelope of consciousness to include all sorts of organisms: other mammals, some species of birds, cephalopods, and even bees. The quest to pinpoint the origins of consciousness in the human brain has given rise to speculation that it may be a fundamental characteristic of matter. Some have even suggested that consciousness resides in the particle world, raising the prospect that the neo-Platonists may have been correct.
I’d become intrigued by the studies of Suzanne Simard showing that conifers are capable of communicating with one another via a network of mycelial fungus in a manner that approximates rudimentary intelligence. She found that the network operates to arbitrate allocation of precious resources, within and between species, very often resolving competing claims in favor of the weakest members of the community. In one experiment, she discovered that a “mother tree” will nurture every sapling within her drip line, whether her progeny or not, but will favor her progeny in the distribution of water and nutrients by a small but measurable amount.
I’d seen the trees around my house do some remarkable things, their way of adjusting their growth to the demands of the environment, for example, or placing branches in dormancy during times of distress as opposed to culling them. I understood that everything I’d witnessed could be explained in terms of simple chemistry, the presence of one enzyme or another in their vascular systems, but that didn’t end the inquiry. The entirety of human history, every noble and ignoble act, can be traced to the serendipities of brain chemistry.
I suspected the trees might be conscious, and that inkling of a shared reality made me wonder what it might feel like to be a tree. Are they aware of themselves and their surroundings, or merely responding to stimulus? Is their awareness centralized or distributed? Do they experience emotion, something like joy when a seed germinates or despair when a sapling perishes? Could we use those affects to establish a bridge between their experience and ours?
That line of inquiry didn’t carry me very far. The trees couldn’t very well tell me what it feels like to be one of them when they sense the world, if they sense it at all, through a different set of mechanisms. It was that paradox of our search for extra-terrestrial intelligence in the universe all over again. When and if we stumble upon it — or, as is more likely, it stumbles upon us — how will we communicate that we’re anything more than a primitive species following the path of least resistance to our own destruction?
Once I divested myself of that myth of human exceptionalism, the trees guided me with their silence to a more apposite set of questions. Am I conscious? Is my consciousness an illusion, an artifact of evolution to help me cope with the fact that, like the trees, I exist at the whim of forces I can hardly fathom? What is my niche in this world when I’ve held myself separate from nature my entire life? Why had I started to feel so bloody lonely in their presence?
It was Carl Jung who stepped in with answers when I needed them. Jung believed we carry an innate need to connect with the archetypes of our past — the sky father, the Earth mother, the burning bush, and the “silly old owl,” to name a few — that conflict with the artificial constructs of the modern world. “People who have got dirty through too much civilization,” he wrote, “take a walk in the woods, or a bath in the sea. They shake off the fetters and allow nature to touch them.”
It is when I stand in awe of the aching beauty and power of nature that I am, myself, most conscious. In those moments, the internal logic of the universe is laid bare. I am connected with every living thing on the planet, not merely by necessity, but also by the fact that we share a common imperative, that compulsion to pass on our genetic heritage.
Jung’s theories, or at least my interpretation of them, beat the hell out of the alternative — that my loneliness in the presence of those trees came down to some repressed Oedipus complex. It helped that I could vouch for his theories from the benefit of personal experience. I’d found a deeper understanding of myself and my place in the world through those trees. The word “spiritual” has fallen into disfavor in our time, unless of course it describes with absolute accuracy how one is feeling.
I wasn’t prepared to proclaim to the world that trees are conscious. But the possibility offered the prospect of something larger than my own puny salvation as the purpose of my life, and the source of that connection, a living world, felt more approachable to me than an implacable God. It was love driving my care for those trees, not fear of eternal punishment. The effort I put into bringing water to them had become an act of worship. Every moment I occupied in their presence was wrapped in a prayer of gratitude for the nurture and beauty of creation.
And then this past summer, the fourth since my conversation with the arborist, I was on the deck indulging myself in the sensory delights of the hour. It was one of those immersive moments in which I managed to lose myself in the rapid succession of inputs, the contrast of warm sun and cooling mist on my face, the sound of waves rolling ashore on the surf, and the fecund aroma of the sea on the breeze.
When I looked up at the Governess with the cockney chatter of a house finch high up in her canopy, I saw something that made me sit up in my chair. Holes had opened in her crown, a tear in that smart boater’s cap, and her parasol had been reduced to a single panel.
I glanced at the other trees, and their condition was mixed. The juvenile spruce seemed to be doing alright, apart from one of them showing a little browning at the tips of her new growth, but the mature trees were in a state of distress.
I’d had doubts before, of course. But all I’d had to do was go out and saturate the ground with water. In my need to believe I was making a difference, I’d managed to ignore the inconvenient truth. Climate change was winning.
If the trees were human, I might have asked them for an advanced directive, and we could debate whether the water I was pouring into the soil amounted to extraordinary measures. If they were family, I might have offered my blessing to assisted suicide. I had no desire to prolong their suffering, but that was exactly what I seemed to be doing. I’d taken the decision for them, not for their sake any longer, but my own.
I decided to put the question to them, in words this time, not thoughts, “Do you want me to stop?” I didn’t get a response, and I didn’t expect one. The trees as I’d come to regard them were above abject pleas for mercy. It was a decision I’d have to make on my own.
I went about my routines for a few weeks, watering when I thought the trees needed it, talking to them at every opportunity whether they needed it or not. But the question continued to haunt me. Was I doing the right thing? A couple of months later, on a fine evening in early October, I got an answer.
Our daughter was in town with her husband and newborn son. She’d just put the baby down for the night, and we were seated around the living room sharing family lore. The sun was about to set, and I excused myself to take in a breath of fresh air. When I stepped out onto the deck, the trees were ablaze in the warm light of dusk, their bearing regal in the waning moments of golden hour.
Before I could offer up my usual salutation, I felt it, the dead weight of my own mortality. It hit me with a crushing sense of personal doom.
I was shocked. Death had been the furthest thing from my mind. My thoughts when I’d ventured out were on family, our daughter, her husband, and infant child, and the prospect of growing old together with my wife in the never-ending cycle of life.
As I struggled to retain my composure, I wondered if I might have missed something in the translation. I’d been about to deliver my usual greeting, with its emphasis on the effects of global climate change. The most I was willing to concede was I might perish before the trees.
When I adjusted the contrast, from the personal to the generic, the message came into focus. The trees in my yard might die of climate change, but their species would go on, as it had in each of the planet’s last three extinction events. I might live to a ripe, old age, but I would die, and the cause might very well be the damage we’re doing our climate.
It was a stay of execution, not a commutation of sentence. At sixty-something, the lifelines on my palms had grown distressingly short. I’d be gone in due course, sooner than later, but the species would simply migrate north, and my daughter and her family would be left to cope with the desolation. I despaired for the world my grandson would inherit.
“Is there no hope?” I asked.
The trees were still, their silhouettes withdrawing in the gathering darkness. But as I waited, a soft breeze stirred off the ocean, moving their branches back and forth in a soothing motion.
The word “awareness” entered my thoughts, not as my state of mind, but as a warning, like the message from one of those Magic 8 Ball toys, where you get an answer to life’s deepest questions coming into focus through that portal into the unknown.
I was grateful, of course. There was the possibility I might avoid the bitter end. We all might. But awareness? Are you kidding me? It was a big word, one that could be stretched to cover almost anything.
I was already aware. “Woke” was more like it — and proud of it. I’d taken the whole “reduce, reuse, and recycle” mantra climate skeptics dismiss as “virtue signaling” to their inevitable extremes. I walked when I could. I drove a hybrid when I couldn’t. I paid a premium to purchase electricity from renewable sources. I’d forsaken air-conditioning during summer months, and I kept the thermostat at a balmy sixty-eight degrees during the winter.
I was watering ancient trees for God’s sake, and in a temperate rainforest!
“What more must I do?” I demanded.
Now that I’d been confronted with my own mortality, I was determined to have an answer. But as I waited, I felt a chill. The temperature had fallen five degrees with twilight, and that gentle breeze had turned frigid. If I was going to wait out a reply, I’d have to bundle up first.
Mike Bates is an aspiring writer who finds inspiration in the natural wonders of the Pacific Northwest. His works of fiction can been found in print and online with journals as diverse as Mobius: the Journal for Social Change and Catamaran Literary Reader. He lives on the Upper Left coast with his wife, Leslie