By: Brittany Borghi
In the summertime, each month, the White Oak Springs Presbyterian Church in Renfrew, Pennsylvania holds one of its Sunday services outdoors. When the parishioners come — from neighboring Butler, from Connoquenessing — they gather under the white painted pine pavilion in the yard and watch as Pastor Lee Dreyer gives his sermon. Nearby, a long, straight stand of poplar trees shade the cemetery, where the headstones rest scattershot.
The congregation sits at brown wooden picnic tables, three long lines perpendicular to the podium where the pastor stands so that members must crane their necks to see the man. Some swing a leg up onto the seat to turn out more comfortably, others bring canvas lawn chairs and prop them out in the sun at the pavilion’s edge.
Dreyer is a tall, slender man with a white beard and wire-rim glasses. He wears a beige suit jacket that looks just right in the summer heat. He majored in English literature at college, and his wife and teenage daughter are among those sitting at the edge of the pavilion in their lawn chairs. In the church bulletin, everyone is invited to attend his daughter’s upcoming senior piano recital and high school graduation party, which will be held in the same pavilion. When Dreyer stands at the small wooden podium, he is blocking a long fold out table covered in Tupperware and Saran-wrapped Dixie plates brimming with homemade cookies and brownies. Two aluminum coffee urns hold hot portions of decaf and regular.
I was born and raised just eight miles away, and all of my family members lived within an hour’s drive of the church. For years, I watched one fracking well pad after another dot the landscape. We had all heard about the potential environmental impact, and yet, the danger remained distant and diffuse: I felt a vague sense of fear every time I saw the sign for a new fracking site pop up at the edge of some bucolic property in the country. Was anyone’s water catching on fire? Was our air filling with some irrevocable parts per million of a permanent and deadly gas? It seemed to me that these were questions most people had accepted that we should ignore. I came to the church service because I’d heard there was a specific community where the effects of fracking couldn’t be ignored — and Dreyer was doing something to help.
As I look at the dessert table, I see that the body of Christ has never seemed so sweet. And so, I listen.
Dreyer reads from Acts 17 when Paul visits the Athenians. He stands up in the Areopagus and says, “People of Athens! I see that in every way you are very religious. For as I walked around and looked carefully at your objects of worship, I even found an altar with this inscription: to an unknown god. So you are ignorant of the very thing you worship.” Paul goes on to proclaim: “The God who made the world and everything in it is the Lord of heaven and earth and does not live in temples built by human hands. And he is not served by human hands, as if he needed anything. Rather, he himself gives everyone life and breath.”
In his homily, Dreyer responds: “Paul is presenting us with a paradox — if we are close to something, we can put our arms around it, but if it’s the most powerful force, then it’s far and distant. I would argue no matter how large and powerful we imagine God to be, God is larger and more powerful than our imaginations can understand. There is a sense in which we all worship an unknown god.”
At the end of the service, the congregation reads the benediction in unison: God be with you till we meet again. Old voices fill in the hollow spaces, and we shake hands and exchange small jokes about getting trapped in the picnic tables. A line peels out of the pavilion toward the cemetery as people queue up for coffee and nut brownies. This is Sunday.
On Monday, a different congregation attends White Oak Springs. Small pickups and weathered sedans drive to the rear of the church one by one, backing in, lowering tailgates and opening trunks, and Dreyer comes out of the church in jeans, his college t-shirt, and a Pittsburgh Penguins hat. He hauls large cardboard boxes into the backs of the vehicles and the people — from a neighborhood just two miles away — joke with Dreyer and the others helping him in the easy way that people accustomed to a habit do. Their gratitude is a known quantity, and Dreyer would feel it even if they didn’t say it. Such is the station of grace.
The cardboard boxes contain twenty gallons of water. Clean, drinkable water. It is the largest supply of free, clean water each family has easy access to, and the most they’ll get for the week. Twenty gallons is the amount given to couples and families of three or four people. Twenty gallons hopes to satisfy the Red Cross formulation for water distribution to people in need: four gallons per person per day. Twenty gallons for a week, Dreyer says, doesn’t quite add up. But it’s all he can do. This water bank, run entirely by volunteers, has been providing clean water to the same people for six full years.
The water comes from the Crystal Springs water company, the same jugs you find at the gas station or grocery store. Dreyer pays for the water entirely through donations. It costs $15,600 to keep the water bank running every year. Checks come from Central Park West, the Thomas Merton Center, an unnamed woman from Boston, and other, anonymous donors. There was only one year the church didn’t have the money to make ends meet, and somehow, they still pulled it off. When people hear about the cause, they feel compelled to give.
White Oak Springs Presbyterian Church sits in the heart of the Marcellus Shale. The Shale formation is a neutral party; it does not mean to harm. But the people who come to get clean water from Dreyer believe that their well water — what they pull out of the ground to drink at their homes — has been contaminated by the companies that have descended on their town to mine the shale for natural gas through the process of hydraulic fracturing. The companies — and the towns those companies pay money to and the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection and the United States Environmental Protection Agency — claim that hydraulic fracturing is in no way responsible for the contamination of those wells, or any other. They say there is no proof — that the chemical markers in the gas that the companies suck out of the shale don’t show up in the tests of these wells — so the companies’ gas has not gotten into those wells, and so the companies are not responsible.
But our water wasn’t contaminated before you started drilling, and now it is, the people say.
Are you sure? the companies ask. Check again.
Meanwhile, no one stops drilling. No water becomes drinkable.
A middle-aged white guy in a cut-off t-shirt named Larry pulls up to the church in a blue Dodge and walks in the back.
“How are you?” asks a volunteer.
“Old, fat, and ugly. How are you?” Larry says.
“That’s not what he said out here!” another person calls through the door.
“I know, I know — I’m just being humble,” Larry says. “You can’t lie in the church.”
Without skipping a beat, he puts his arms around a cardboard box holding five gallons of water. Dreyer follows behind him with another. Then two more cardboard boxes are loaded in. This is ritual, this is chore. Larry shoots the shit for another minute or two then drives away, only to be replaced moments later by a green Pontiac. The ebb and flow continues for a couple of hours, until the needs of the fifty families who depend on the water bank are met. Those who can’t show up at the arranged time deputize a neighbor as proxy.
Every week, the water bank switches from a morning to a night shift, so that it’s fair and convenient. Dreyer is always there to work the bank, and different volunteers fill in to pick up the slack. No one would ever suggest that these cardboard boxes, these plastic jugs, have been allowed to take the place of any god, but by the looks of it, they have the power to fill the space between what is sacred and what is scarce. If we can put our arms around it, then it is close. If it is far and distant, Dreyer said, it is the most powerful force.
Fred and Janet McIntyre noticed right away when the fracking started in Butler County in 2011. They live in the Woodlands — the neighborhood that the water bank was built to serve. The neighborhood was initially designated as recreational land for sportsmen — western Pennsylvania gentry built hunting cabins there in the late 1800s, but by the middle of the twentieth century, people looking for life outside of town turned the Woodlands into a permanent home. It isn’t a defined or designated area like a housing plan, just an amalgamation of properties out in the woods where people decided to go because they could — or because they needed to. The area is dominated by small one-story homes and trailers, gravel and dirt roads, and lower-income families. It never lost its designation as a formal recreation area. Because of this, the Woodlands doesn’t get municipal water or trash service from the municipal entity, Connoquenessing Borough, whose motto is: A Long Way Straight. That’s also the meaning of Connoquenessing, a Native American Delaware word. Since the borough doesn’t officially claim the people in the Woodlands, they drill their own wells, long and straight into the ground.
The first official record of Janet showing up to talk with the Connoquenessing Township supervisors about her water dates from December 5, 2012. She says the supervisors were very sympathetic at first. Willing to hear her out. She was nervous to get up and speak at a public meeting, something she’d never had to do before.
People from the Woodlands had already complained about the state of their water to the supervisors, and Rex Energy — the company responsible for the drilling in the area surrounding the Woodlands — was giving free water to some of those people in 2011 and early 2012. Rex Energy would fill giant plastic tubs — called water buffaloes — every two weeks for some of the people in the Woodlands. Each person received 1,550 gallons — and they stretched it for as long as possible. It was what they used for eating, drinking, bathing — even doing the dishes. At least fifty families in the Woodlands had been affected by water contamination, and those who weren’t getting water buffaloes from Rex got their water from White Oak Springs. But in February of 2012, Rex decided to pay for its own private study of the water contamination issue in the Woodlands, with its own private researchers, working in conjunction with the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection. What the researchers found was amazing.
Since the specific, complex chemical signature that Rex places in its natural gas could not be found in the water which came up from the wells drilled in the Woodlands, the Rex researchers concluded that there were no notable differences in pre- and post-drilling water chemistry in Connoquenessing. The Associated Press published an article on the issue with a headline that read “Connoquenessing Water OK.” Rex representatives came by to all the houses where they’d been filling water buffaloes and dumped the water out on the ground in front of the homes. An old man pleaded with the Rex employees, saying it was all the water he had to drink, that he wouldn’t make a fuss. The man said Rex dumped it anyway.
At the water bank, Janet pulls a mason jar of muddy-looking water out of her purse and shakes it up. She pops the seal and hands the open jar to me.
“That’s from Russ Kelly’s house this week. Smell it,” Janet says.
“Smells like nail polish remover.”
Janet purses her lips and nods her head at me.
Fred and Janet’s house is at the end of a bunny-hilled dirt road full of ruts. Mike, who helps run a local activist group against fracking in Butler County, drives me there. Cows graze on the hillside. Old, rusting things throw contrast up on all the green: upturned riding mowers and cars spray-painted matte black. A couple of stately propane tanks. A half-dozen ride-on plastic children’s toys all in a line: a magenta Barbie Jeep, a miniature John Deere tractor, a washed-out red Corvette, and a baby pink Big Wheel, kept as a reminder of another time.
Janet’s old water buffalo is snuggled next to the house where Fred rigged up an internal pipe to siphon the water inside. The water buffalo is empty, and has been for years, hemmed in by large rhubarb leaves, an old tire, and a wooden table covered in electrical cable and supplies. The house itself is visual resistance — or dance. Colors constantly dart and change, the way your frame is always full of something new when you walk through a dry streambed: calcite and sandstone, new leaves and anxious toads blow in and out of sight. Janet’s house is the type of place that should be precisely where it is. When Janet comes out of the side door, I can hear another person talking, food on the stove, Judge Judy doling out easy justice.
Janet says she and Fred and a few others in the Woodlands are plaintiffs in a lawsuit against Rex, so she can’t talk much more about the situation. Dreyer says the suit has been stuck in legal gridlock for several years: there’s no way the homeowners can stand up to the corporation.
By the end of the summer, two new families have joined the fifty others lining up for water from White Oak Springs. One of them is Janet’s daughter and her family, who ran into some trouble and moved their trailer onto the ground next to Janet’s house.
The extra forty gallons for the two new families haven’t put White Oak Springs in a bind — they still hold the water bank every Monday, and only a couple of people have moved out of the neighborhood.
“We’re still taking contributions, and everything’s moving on in the same way since the last time we talked,” Dreyer says. “And I would add: there’s no end in sight.”
The tone in Dreyer’s voice goes beyond resignation. He is near retirement; his family life is moving forward; his daughter is going off to college. He’s just moved into a new house in Butler farther away from the church, and he’s preparing to leave his job in the next few years. He doesn't speculate about what will happen to the water bank.
In his sermon back in May, Dreyer said, “It is a hard world in which we live, but there is no cause to be afraid. If we stand on the horizon between what we know and don’t know about God, if we could imagine that God is infinitely large but also more intimate than we could expect, what would happen?”
Another world would open up. We’d jump the tracks to another timeline. The ground, pockmarked with old and rotting mines, deep pores where oil and coal had long ago been sucked out, would fill back up with dirt. The current wells, all those horizontal fracks lying fallow — dusty arteries where strange gasses float and disperse into the ground water, condensing into manganese and iron streams — all of them would zip their fault lines closed, belching something slightly noxious at the top before a soil cap flips closed like the mouth of a kettle when its boil stops.
In that other world, the oil that seeps to the surface is enough. In 1859, Colonel Edwin Drake drills ten feet north in Tidioute, and the tract comes back dry. Tired, he notes the Seneca really have something with their creek baskets — they haul up what’s there, they use it. We find a more efficient way to fly around the world, to heat our houses. Other, clearer answers arise. We scoop handfuls of oil from the seep ponds in the forest and rub down our muscles in August to keep the mosquitos at bay. We all smell like leather, like Cabernet. If we stand on the horizon and imagine an intimate god, a close god, a god who seals up the cracks in this world where the only curves in the ground get cut by clean water and melting snow, if we stand on the horizon and imagine a god of magnitude, we slip the boundary between this reality and the next, like a set of five fingers rolling smoothly over a stone. We get stuck between the knuckles we like.
Dreyer looks at me, adjusts his glasses, and says, “I was talking about Heaven.”
I stood there looking at him, thinking of the work he and everyone else had done: the waterbank, the Woodlands, and the years of organization, donations, and service. Despite every obstacle, they provided people with an essential service that the people could wrap their arms around. Their power wasn’t far and distant — it was right here.
The pastor wanted to talk about creating beauty in the next world.
I was hoping to tell him: they had built the beauty together in this one.
Brittany Borghi is a Fulbright fellow whose work has appeared in The Iowa Review, The Hopkins Review, Guesthouse, and Entropy, among others. She is a 2018 graduate of the Nonfiction Writing Program at the University of Iowa. She lives and teaches in Pittsburgh, PA.